What is the job of a Magistrate?
The job of a magistrate consists of deciding legal cases as a member of a court, applying the law to specific situations: a dispute between people, a crime, a complaint against a public body or an appeal against another judge's ruling. In many countries the term is used for those who sit on higher courts or appeal courts, and in others it is simply another word for a judge. For that reason it is worth checking how each country's system defines it.
A typical day mixes reading, study and deliberation. Case files and the parties' written arguments are reviewed, the laws and earlier rulings that may apply are analyzed, and hearings are attended. Then, together with the other members of the court when it is a panel, each case is discussed, a vote is taken and a decision is written that explains with reasons why the case was decided that way. A large part of the day is spent quietly, with documents and legal texts.
Typical tasks
- Studying the case files and the evidence presented by each of the parties.
- Leading or taking part in hearings and listening to the arguments of lawyers, prosecutors and others.
- Analyzing which rules and earlier court decisions apply to each case.
- Deliberating with the other members of the court and voting on the decision.
- Writing rulings and decisions with a clear and well-organized explanation of the reasons.
- Reviewing the decisions of lower-court judges when an appeal is filed.
- Supervising the work of the court or chamber team, such as law clerks, registrars and administrative staff.
Subjects and content usually covered
- Civil, criminal, labor and administrative law, depending on the area of work.
- Constitutional law and human rights.
- Procedural law: how trials, deadlines and appeals work.
- Legal theory and the interpretation of rules.
- Legal reasoning and the writing of rulings.
- Judicial ethics and the independence of the courts.
- Specific training for the judicial role, which in several countries is taken at a judicial school.
Usual duration and type of training
There is no single route. The law degree usually lasts 4 to 6 years, depending on the country, and in some countries law is studied as a graduate program after a first degree. After that, in many cases, several years of professional experience are added, and in some countries also specific training for the judicial role or a postgraduate course, lasting 1 to 3 years. In total, reaching this position usually takes well over a decade, because it is normally held by people with previous experience. Everything varies a great deal from one country to another.
How you get there and what is usually required to practice
People arrive from a law degree. After that there are two main paths: the judicial career, which starts in support posts inside the courts or as a judge in a first-instance court and moves up through promotions, and direct appointment to a higher court, for which experience as a lawyer, prosecutor, teacher or judge is asked for.
In many countries the requirements include a law qualification, a minimum age, years of professional practice and passing a competition, an exam or a review of one's record. Depending on the country, the appointment is made by a judicial council, the executive branch, the legislature or a combination of them. There are also usually conduct requirements and rules on incompatibility with other activities.
Skills that help
- Reading long, complex texts closely and spotting the points that really matter.
- Analyzing rules and earlier decisions to work out which applies to each case.
- Writing in a clear, orderly and reasoned way so that the parties can understand the decision.
- Listening to all parties equally, without reaching conclusions early.
- Deliberating with others, defending a view with arguments and accepting the majority's decision.
- Keeping cases confidential and acting independently of outside pressure.
Career paths and job opportunities
- Appeal courts and chambers that review the rulings of other judges.
- Supreme courts or courts of cassation.
- Constitutional courts, in the countries that have them.
- Administrative, labor, family or criminal courts.
- International or regional human rights courts, in some cases.
What you are not always told
- The amount of reading and writing is very large, and decisions are made with long case files and deadlines that are sometimes tight.
- Every ruling affects the lives of real people, and that responsibility weighs, especially in criminal or family cases.
- Decisions can attract public criticism, and discretion and distance are expected in personal life and on social media.
- There are restrictions: in many countries the person cannot practice as a lawyer or take part in politics while holding the post.
- Reaching this position takes many years, and there is no automatic promotion: it depends on competitions, evaluations and appointments.
How the field is changing
Case files are moving from paper to digital systems, and many hearings are held with the help of recording or video connection. Case-law search engines and document analysis tools help organize and consult large quantities of text, although the decision remains with the person who judges. There are also growing debates about the use of artificial intelligence in justice, data protection and transparency, and rulings written in plainer language are being asked for.
In several countries, ways of settling disputes outside a trial, such as mediation, are also being expanded, and the way courts are selected and evaluated is being reviewed.
Want to know if this is the right career for you?
Take the free vocational test with 5 scientific methods — CHASIDE, Holland, Big Five, MMMG and VAK — to get your personalized profile. You can also explore all university careers or learn about the scientific methodology.